Best Restaurants in Indianapolis Indiana

Best Restaurants in Indianapolis Indiana include a historic steakhouse, a century-old deli, German beer hall classics, seasonal New American cooking, and soul food. Several of these spots have fed the city for over 100 years.

Fallback-Slide-1Fallback-Slide-1
Fallback-Slide-2Fallback-Slide-2
Fallback-Slide-3Fallback-Slide-3
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3

St. Elmo Steak House — Downtown Landmark Since 1902

St. Elmo has served steaks on South Illinois Street since 1902. It’s the city’s oldest steakhouse still in its original location. The famous shrimp cocktail comes with a fiery horseradish sauce that clears sinuses fast. Additionally, the wine cellar holds around 20,000 bottles. Reservations are recommended, though walk-ins are welcome.

Shapiro’s Delicatessen — Piled-High Deli Sandwiches Since 1905

Shapiro’s started as a family grocery on South Meridian Street in 1905. Four generations later, it’s still run by the same family. Corned beef, pastrami, and peppered beef sandwiches are the classic orders. Meanwhile, matzo ball soup and homemade mac and cheese are popular sides. Weekend mornings add a breakfast menu.

The Rathskeller — German Food in Indy’s Oldest Restaurant

The Rathskeller has operated since 1894 inside the historic Athenaeum building. Schnitzel, sauerbraten, and oxtail soup reflect the building’s German roots. Also, the Kellerbar pours a long list of imported and local beers. The outdoor biergarten hosts live music when the weather is nice. It’s a fun pick for groups.

Bluebeard — Seasonal Cooking in a 1924 Warehouse

Bluebeard sits on Virginia Avenue in the Fletcher Place neighborhood. Its name and decor nod to Indianapolis author Kurt Vonnegut. The menu changes often, built around local produce and meat. Plus, bread comes from Amelia’s, the bakery next door. Some dining room tables can be reserved, while the bar stays walk-in only.

Kountry Kitchen Soul Food Place — Southern Cooking on College Avenue

Kountry Kitchen began in 1988 as a six-seat counter diner. After closing for a few years, it reopened in a new building at its original site in 2023. Fried catfish, smothered pork chops, and collard greens are menu staples. Even so, candied yams and mac and cheese often steal the show. Weekend hours start early for breakfast.

Final Bite

Indianapolis mixes deep food history with modern neighborhood favorites. Even so, downtown and nearby Fletcher Place offer the easiest starting points for visitors.