Best Restaurants in Fishers Indiana: From Fishers District to the Nickel Plate District

Best Restaurants in Fishers Indiana range from Fishers District steakhouses to Nickel Plate District breweries. Italian dining, seafood, and breakfast spots fill out the list. Because Fishers keeps growing, this guide lists only restaurants that are open today.

Fallback-Slide-1Fallback-Slide-1
Fallback-Slide-2Fallback-Slide-2
Fallback-Slide-3Fallback-Slide-3
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3

Peterson’s — Prime Steaks and an Award-Winning Wine Library

Peterson’s serves prime steaks and fresh seafood at 7690 East 96th Street. Joe Peterson opened the family-owned restaurant in 1999. Additionally, its wine library of more than 200 labels earned a Wine Spectator honor in 2026. Because it serves dinner Monday through Saturday, plan an evening visit.

1933 Lounge by St. Elmo — A Speakeasy-Style Steakhouse at Fishers District

1933 Lounge by St. Elmo serves steak, seafood, and sushi at 9707 District North Drive, Suite 1120. The speakeasy-style lounge sits at The Yard at Fishers District and welcomes guests 21 and older. Additionally, it serves classic St. Elmo cocktails and the world-famous shrimp cocktail. Plus, the Fishers location offers a full lunch and dinner menu.

The HC Tavern + Kitchen — Upscale American Grill at Fishers District

The HC Tavern + Kitchen serves elevated American comfort food at 9709 East 116th Street. The two-story restaurant has two bars, a wine tower, and an upstairs patio. Additionally, favorites include the Lobster Cargot, wagyu corn dogs, and St. Elmo’s shrimp cocktail. Plus, weekend brunch runs from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Sangiovese Ristorante — Family-Owned Italian at Fishers District

Sangiovese Ristorante serves handcrafted Italian cuisine at 9708 District North Drive. The family-owned restaurant has served authentic Italian food since 1994. Additionally, the Fishers District location brings many of the original recipes to its menu. Because dinner service begins at 5 p.m., plan an evening visit.

Tiburon Coastal Cuisine — Sushi, Seafood, and Steaks in the Nickel Plate District

Tiburon Coastal Cuisine serves sushi, seafood, and steaks at 8701 East 116th Street, Suite 160. The owners of Monterey Coastal Cuisine in Carmel opened it in June 2024. Additionally, the menu features blackened grouper with lobster risotto and a full cocktail program. Plus, the restaurant opens daily at 11 a.m.

101 Craft Kitchen — Scratch-Made Dining Near Fishers District

101 Craft Kitchen serves chef-driven, scratch-made food at 9708 District North Drive, Suite 910. The restaurant sits less than a mile from the Fishers Event Center. Additionally, its menu focuses on rustic, seasonal dishes paired with craft beer and cocktails. Plus, weekend brunch and a patio add variety.

Four Day Ray Brewing — Scratch Kitchen and Award-Winning Beer

Four Day Ray Brewing is a family-friendly scratch kitchen and brewery at 11671 Lantern Road. The brewery has operated in Fishers since 2016 in the Nickel Plate District. Additionally, its rotating taps feature award-winning beers brewed on site. Because the kitchen opens daily at 11 a.m., it works for lunch or dinner.

Another Broken Egg Cafe — Southern-Inspired Breakfast and Brunch

Another Broken Egg Cafe serves southern-inspired breakfast, brunch, and lunch at 8626 East 116th Street, Suite 175. The cafe sits near the corner of East 116th Street and Municipal Drive. Additionally, handcrafted drinks, online ordering, and catering round out the offerings. Plus, it opens daily from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Conclusion: Dining in Fishers

Fishers pairs upscale steakhouses with Italian dining, coastal seafood, craft beer, and southern-style brunch. Because many spots sit in Fishers District and the Nickel Plate District, visitors can sample several in one outing. In fact, every restaurant on this list is real, currently open, and inside Fishers.