Best Restaurants in Evansville Indiana

Best Restaurants in Evansville Indiana include a historic tavern famous for brain sandwiches, a German beer hall, and a hometown Tex-Mex favorite. The city’s West Side holds two of its most iconic spots.

Fallback-Slide-1Fallback-Slide-1
Fallback-Slide-2Fallback-Slide-2
Fallback-Slide-3Fallback-Slide-3
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3

Hilltop Inn — Fried Brain Sandwiches in an 1839 Stagecoach Stop

Hilltop Inn started as a stagecoach stop in 1839 on Evansville’s West Side. Today, it’s best known for the jumbo fried pork brain sandwich, served with pickles and onions. First-timers can try brain sliders instead of a full sandwich. Additionally, burgoo, German fries, and fried livers and gizzards fill out the menu. It’s a casual tavern with cold beer and a local crowd.

Gerst Haus — German Food and Giant Beer Fishbowls

Gerst Haus has served German food on Franklin Street since 1999. Wiener schnitzel, bratwurst, and sauerbraten are menu standbys. Meanwhile, giant frozen fishbowls of the house Gerst Amber beer are a signature. The bar pours around 50 draft beers, and there’s a patio too. Reservations are taken Sunday through Thursday.

Hacienda Mexican Restaurant — Wet Burritos Since 1978

Hacienda opened in Evansville in 1978 and has grown into a regional favorite. Wet burritos are the dish that made it famous. Plus, fresh chips and salsa and frozen margaritas keep regulars coming back. Several locations across town make it easy to find. The original First Avenue spot carries the most history.

Final Bite

Evansville’s food scene leans on deep local traditions. Even so, the brain sandwich at Hilltop Inn is the one dish visitors will remember most.